»Ê¼Ò»ªÈË

SFI still not accessible in the uplands

17 October 2022

Thomas Binns

Thomas Binns

NFU Uplands Forum chair

Thomas Binns in the foreground leaning on his shepherd's crook, with his farm scenery and sheep in the background
NFU Uplands Forum chair, Thomas Binns, provides an update on hill farming issues, and reports on the frustration felt by many Forum members on the lack of progress with Environmental Land Management schemes.

What a year it has been on many fronts. Whilst the weather here in the North West has delivered us with just-in-time rain showers, I am acutely aware that has not been the case for many farmers around most of the country!

Climate and economic challenges

The continued impact of the prolonged dry spell can be clearly seen in many reservoirs, where water levels are really low. »Ê¼Ò»ªÈËcontinues to monitor the situation and has continually raised with government the need for a fresh approach and a commitment to national water infrastructure. In the uplands too much rain is often more of a problem.

There is no doubt that the climate is changing and while we are all responding to the urgent need to do what we can to reduce our own impacts, we are also looking at where we can adapt our farming practices.

Just like the weather, we have no control over the challenges we face when it comes to energy supply either. Triple digit inflation for some farm inputs has created real issues for many farmers including here in the uplands.

Many of our recent stock sales have reported buoyant returns for sellers, but the input costs associated with the next production cycle will be eye-watering so once again we will all need to be clear in our business thinking and planning. In some sectors that may mean reduced production levels – with associated knock-on effects for us all.

SFI remains inaccessible

Within the context of planning for the future, it is still very disappointing that the SFI 2022 scheme remains inaccessible for many upland farmers – especially those with commons or environmental schemes still in place. It is extremely frustrating that despite our regular dialogue with Defra, the uplands in general seems to lag behind when it comes to actual delivery. If you are experiencing difficulty with SFI 2022 please get in touch with Call First or your regional office.

Further levels of SFI are still in the pipeline along with the Local Nature Recovery element of ELM. It is unlikely you will be able to assess how or if it fits with your business going forward until 2024. 

It is easy to become despondent about the progress of the ELM schemes and that frustration is felt by many Uplands Forum members who sit on a number of SFI and LNR development groups, especially when faced with a strong theme of ‘reducing livestock’. SFI is about sustainable farming specifically and needs to work alongside viable farming businesses to support the environment.

Well-managed livestock deliver benefits for the environment

We will continue to fight for livestock in the hills and support our vision with work from research organisations on the benefit of well-managed livestock to the environment. Defra has a stated ambition for SFI to appeal to at least 70% of BPS claimants. However, unless the scheme is attractive to farmers – offering a simple, well-rewarded and easily administered approach – they may well find that their ambition is not easily fulfilled. Let’s also not forget that by 2024 BPS will have been reduced by 50%.

The Farming In Protected Landscape (FiPL) programme is another source of funding that some of you will have heard of and possibly applied for. As the title suggests, it is primarily aimed at funding activity in National Parks and AONBs. It’s worth pointing out that if you farm just outside these designations you can still apply as there is a responsibility to consider these applications.

Since the concept of an agricultural transition period was first introduced – managing the journey from the Common Agriculture Policy to our new domestic arrangements – much has changed both at home and across the globe.

Food security must be a national priority

Food security, including securing our domestic production base, has to be a national priority. Securing the future of farming and farmers is central to being able to successfully deliver for both the good of society and the uplands!

On the Uplands Forum, our foremost priority is to continue to remind the government and others that upland farming can contribute significantly to both the food and climate change agendas. However, to ensure that we can maximise our contribution to the nation and remain financially viable, we must secure domestic farming policies that are fit for purpose and have farmers front and centre of development and delivery.


Ask us a question about this page

Once you have submitted your query someone from NFU CallFirst will contact you. If needed, your query will then be passed to the appropriate NFU policy team.

You have 0 characters remaining.

By completing the form with your details on this page, you are agreeing to have this information sent to the NFU for the purposes of contacting you regarding your enquiry. Please take time to read the NFU’s Privacy Notice if you require further information.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google and apply.